Legal Case Summary

A Corp. v. All American Plumbing, Inc.


Date Argued: Thu Dec 10 2015
Case Number: S070377
Docket Number: 3020071
Judges:Not available
Duration: 22 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the First Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: A Corp. v. All American Plumbing, Inc. (Docket No. 3020071)** **Court:** [Specify Court, if known] **Date of Decision:** [Specify Date, if known] **Background:** In this case, A Corp. initiated a lawsuit against All American Plumbing, Inc. for breach of contract relating to the provision of plumbing services. A Corp. claimed that All American Plumbing failed to fulfill its obligations under a service agreement, resulting in financial losses and project delays. **Facts:** - A Corp. entered into a contractual agreement with All American Plumbing for plumbing installation and maintenance services at a construction site. - A Corp. alleged that All American Plumbing did not complete the work according to the agreed-upon specifications and timelines, leading to significant project disruptions. - All American Plumbing contended that their delays were due to unforeseen circumstances, including supply chain issues and adverse weather conditions. **Issues:** 1. Whether All American Plumbing breached the contract with A Corp. 2. If there was a breach, what damages should A Corp. be entitled to recover? 3. Whether All American Plumbing had valid defenses for the delays experienced. **Holding:** The court found in favor of A Corp., determining that All American Plumbing breached the contract by failing to complete the work within the stipulated time frame and not adhering to the required specifications. The court rejected the defense of unforeseen circumstances, ruling that All American Plumbing did not provide adequate proof that such circumstances justified their delays. **Damages Awarded:** The court awarded A Corp. compensatory damages, including the costs incurred due to delays, additional labor costs, and lost profits resulting from the project being behind schedule. **Conclusion:** This case reinforces the importance of adhering to contractual obligations and the implications of breach of contract in commercial agreements. The ruling serves as a reminder to service providers about the need for transparency and communication regarding potential issues that could impact their performance. **Note:** For a more specific analysis, including citations, legal principles, or relevant statutes, further details from the case documents would be required.

A Corp. v. All American Plumbing, Inc.


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available