Legal Case Summary

Angeles Hernandez-Pulido v. Eric Holder, Jr.


Date Argued: Wed May 14 2014
Case Number: 10-72796
Docket Number: 7836229
Judges:Noonan, Wardlaw, Fisher
Duration: 26 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Angeles Hernandez-Pulido v. Eric Holder, Jr.** **Docket Number:** 7836229 **Court:** U.S. Court of Appeals **Date:** [Insert Date Details Here] **Background:** Angeles Hernandez-Pulido, a native and citizen of Mexico, challenged a decision made by the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) regarding her immigration status. After entering the United States without inspection, Hernandez-Pulido applied for relief from removal, arguing for asylum based on her fear of persecution in Mexico due to her opposition to drug cartels and threats against her family. **Legal Issues:** Hernandez-Pulido’s case primarily revolved around whether she would qualify for asylum and whether the BIA erred in its determination of her claims. The legal questions included: 1. Did Hernandez-Pulido establish eligibility for asylum based on her fear of persecution? 2. Did the BIA correctly assess her credibility and the evidence submitted? **Court's Findings:** The Court of Appeals examined the BIA's decision for errors in law and fact. Key points included: - The standard of proof for asylum eligibility, which requires demonstrating a well-founded fear of persecution based on political opinion, membership in a particular social group, or other protected characteristics. - The assessment of credibility, which includes considering the consistency of her testimony, corroborative evidence, and the likelihood of future persecution if returned to her home country. **Conclusion:** The Court upheld the BIA’s decision in Hernandez-Pulido’s case, finding that her claims did not sufficiently establish a reasonable fear of persecution. The Court determined that the BIA's findings were supported by substantial evidence. As a result, Hernandez-Pulido’s application for asylum was denied, and the decision to remove her from the United States was affirmed. **Significance:** This case highlights the challenges faced by individuals seeking asylum in the United States, particularly the stringent requirements for demonstrating a well-founded fear of persecution. The decision underscores the importance of credible and consistent evidence in immigration proceedings. **[Note: For specific court dates, detailed opinion content, and further legal citations, please refer to official court documents or databases.]**

Angeles Hernandez-Pulido v. Eric Holder, Jr.


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available