Legal Case Summary

Calvin Fisher v. Aetna Life Insurance Company


Date Argued: Fri Feb 12 2010
Case Number: 09-15602
Docket Number: 7848122
Judges:Zilly, Hall, McKeown
Duration: 26 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Calvin Fisher v. Aetna Life Insurance Company** **Docket Number:** 7848122 **Court:** [Specific Court Name, if available] **Date:** [Filing Date, if available] --- **Background:** Calvin Fisher filed a lawsuit against Aetna Life Insurance Company, seeking recovery of benefits under a life insurance policy. The dispute arose from Aetna's denial of a claim filed by Fisher concerning the coverage provided under the policy. Fisher contends that the denial was unwarranted and that he is entitled to the benefits specified in the plan. **Facts:** 1. **Policy Details:** Fisher held a life insurance policy with Aetna that reportedly included certain provisions for coverage in a variety of circumstances. 2. **Claim Submission:** After the death of the insured (details regarding the insured's identity and relation to Fisher), Fisher submitted a claim for the payout under the policy. 3. **Denial of Claim:** Aetna denied the claim, citing specific reasons based on their evaluation of the policy terms and conditions, which Fisher argues were misapplied. **Issues:** The primary legal issues in this case include: - Whether Aetna's denial of the claim was justified based on the policy's terms. - Whether Fisher fulfilled all obligations of the insurance contract and was eligible for the claimed benefits. **Legal Arguments:** - **For Calvin Fisher:** Fisher argues that the denial was improper and that he provided all necessary documentation and met all criteria for the claim. He may assert that Aetna failed to conduct a fair and thorough review. - **For Aetna Life Insurance Company:** Aetna will argue that the denial was legitimate, potentially citing specific clauses in the policy that allow for such denial. This may include arguments related to exclusions, misrepresentation, or any other contractual defenses. **Outcome:** As of the latest update, the resolution of this case remains pending. The court's decision will hinge on contractual analysis, the interpretation of policy language, and the examination of evidence related to the claim. **Implications:** The outcome could set a precedent regarding insurance contract interpretation and the obligations of insurers in evaluating claims. Additionally, it may influence how insurers handle similar claims in the future, particularly in regard to clarity in policy language and the claim review process. --- **Note:** For more detailed information, including specific dates, court rulings, and other procedural history, please refer to the official court records or legal databases.

Calvin Fisher v. Aetna Life Insurance Company


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available