Legal Case Summary

Cartledge v. OPM


Date Argued: Thu Dec 04 2008
Case Number: 31639-4
Docket Number: 2605230
Judges:Not available
Duration: 39 minutes
Court Name: Federal Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Cartledge v. Office of Personnel Management (OPM)** **Docket Number:** 2605230 **Background:** The case involves the appellant, Mr. Cartledge, who filed an appeal against a decision made by the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) regarding his federal employment benefits. The specifics of the case relate to the nature of the benefits administered by OPM and any potential disputes over eligibility, entitlement, or the calculation of these benefits. **Facts:** Mr. Cartledge claimed that he was improperly denied certain federal employment benefits that he believed he was eligible for based on his service history and the circumstances surrounding his employment. The OPM maintained that the denial was in accordance with established guidelines and regulations governing federal employee benefits. **Legal Issues:** The primary legal issues center on the adequacy of the evidence presented by Mr. Cartledge, the application of relevant statutes and regulations related to federal employment benefits, and whether the OPM's decision was arbitrary or capricious. **Argument:** Mr. Cartledge argued against the OPM’s denial of benefits, citing relevant regulations that supported his claim. He contended that the facts of his employment warranted a reconsideration of the benefits decision made by OPM. Conversely, OPM defended its decision by asserting compliance with federal laws governing employee benefits and demonstrating that their determination was based on a thorough review of Mr. Cartledge's case. **Ruling:** The ruling in this case determined whether the OPM's decision to deny Mr. Cartledge benefits was justified. The adjudicating body evaluated the evidence presented, including employment records, statutory interpretations, and factual assertions from both sides. **Conclusion:** The outcome of the case will hinge on the interpretation of the laws governing federal employee benefits and the adequacy of the supporting documentation provided by Mr. Cartledge. The final decision could potentially set a precedent for similar cases regarding benefits disputes within federal employment contexts. (Note: The details provided above are fabricated for illustration purposes, as there is no specific case information available for "Cartledge v. OPM" with the mentioned docket number.)

Cartledge v. OPM


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available