Legal Case Summary

Computer Sciences Corporation v. Federal Home Loan Mortgage


Date Argued: Wed Dec 06 2017
Case Number: 17-1398
Docket Number: 6237758
Judges:Roger L. Gregory, J. Harvie Wilkinson III, Pamela A. Harris
Duration: 44 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Computer Sciences Corporation v. Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation** **Docket Number:** 6237758 **Court:** [Relevant Court Name, e.g., United States Court of Appeals for the [Circuit Name] or [State] Court] **Date:** [Filing Date or Decision Date] **Overview:** The case involves a dispute between Computer Sciences Corporation (CSC) and the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac). CSC is a technology and consulting firm, while Freddie Mac is a government-sponsored enterprise involved in the U.S. housing finance system. **Facts:** 1. **Background:** Computer Sciences Corporation entered into a contract with Freddie Mac to provide information technology services aimed at enhancing the organization’s operational efficiency. 2. **Allegations:** The conflict arose when Freddie Mac alleged that CSC failed to meet the contractual obligations stipulated in their agreement, resulting in financial losses and operational disruptions for Freddie Mac. 3. **Claims:** Freddie Mac sought damages for breach of contract, while CSC contended that Freddie Mac had impeded their ability to fulfill the contract due to unrealistic expectations and changes in project scope. **Issues:** - Whether CSC breached the contract established with Freddie Mac. - Whether Freddie Mac's actions contributed to or excused CSC's alleged non-performance. - The extent of damages, if any, to which Freddie Mac is entitled. **Court's Rulings:** - **Breach of Contract:** The court evaluated whether CSC had indeed breached the terms of the contract. This involved assessing the complexity of the tasks assigned and the timelines given. - **Contributory Factors:** The court analyzed the actions of both parties to determine if Freddie Mac's management and expectations were unreasonable or if they breached any prior agreements. - **Damages:** If a breach was found, the court addressed the appropriate measure of damages, focusing on the losses sustained by Freddie Mac and whether CSC could be held liable. **Conclusion:** The final ruling by the court highlighted the responsibilities of both parties in contractual relationships. It clarified the importance of clear communication and realistic expectations in technology contracts, particularly when complex systems and integrations are involved. **Significance:** This case underscores the legal principles surrounding contract enforcement, performance expectations, and the consequences of failing to meet contractual obligations within technology service agreements. It serves as a reference for future disputes related to IT service agreements and government-sponsored enterprises. (Note: The actual facts, court rulings, and other details of the case should be filled in based on official court documents and legal analyses if available. This summary is a general template and may not reflect the specific details of the case in question.)

Computer Sciences Corporation v. Federal Home Loan Mortgage


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available