Legal Case Summary

County of Butte, CA v. FERC


Date Argued: Tue Jul 19 2011
Case Number: 10-70140
Docket Number: 7845357
Judges:Tashima, Rawlinson, Cjj Rakoff (S. New York), Dj
Duration: 36 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: County of Butte, CA v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)** **Docket Number**: 7845357 **Court**: United States Court of Appeals **Date**: [Insert Date if known] **Background**: The case involves the County of Butte, California, challenging a decision made by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). The dispute centers around federal regulatory authority over energy resources and potential implications for local governance and community interests. **Facts**: The County of Butte filed a complaint regarding FERC's actions or decisions which the County believed negatively impacted local resources, environmental regulations, or economic concerns within its jurisdiction. The County argued that FERC overstepped its regulatory authority or failed to consider local environmental statutes and community needs when making decisions affecting energy projects in the area. **Legal Issues**: The principal legal questions arose regarding: 1. The extent of FERC’s regulatory authority under federal law versus local governance rights. 2. Whether FERC adequately considered local laws and environmental impacts in its decision-making processes. 3. The implications of FERC’s actions on local land use and resource management. **Arguments**: - **County of Butte, CA**: The County contended that FERC's decisions disregarded local statutes and failed to incorporate essential environmental reviews. They asserted that the commission's actions undermined community interests and local regulatory frameworks. - **Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)**: FERC defended its authority and regulatory decisions, arguing that it acted within its powers to ensure the reliability and efficiency of the national energy supply. The Commission maintained that it complied with federal laws and regulations in its assessments. **Decision**: [Insert the Court's decision if known, including the Court’s reasoning, whether it upheld FERC's decision or sided with Butte County, and any significant legal precedents or interpretations established.] **Impact**: The case has implications for the balance of power between federal energy regulation and local governance, particularly in energy production areas. Depending on the outcome, it may influence future regulatory frameworks and the ability of local governments to enforce environmental protections and land use regulations in relation to energy projects. **Note**: Specific details regarding the court's ruling and its implications would typically be found in the court’s opinion or subsequent legal analyses published post-hearing.

County of Butte, CA v. FERC


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available