Legal Case Summary

Del Webb Communities, Inc. v. Charles Partington


Date Argued: Fri May 13 2011
Case Number: 10-15975
Docket Number: 7845795
Judges:Rosenthal, Fletcher B. , Thomas
Duration: 34 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Del Webb Communities, Inc. v. Charles Partington, Docket No. 7845795** **Court:** [Specify the court if known, e.g., Superior Court, District Court] **Date:** [Specify the date of the decision or filing] **Background:** Del Webb Communities, Inc. is a corporation involved in the development and sale of residential properties. The case arose when Charles Partington, a homeowner, entered into a contractual agreement with Del Webb Communities for the purchase of a home in one of their developments. Disputes emerged regarding the terms of the contract, including allegations of breach of contract, misrepresentation, and issues related to home construction standards. **Facts:** - Del Webb Communities, Inc. marketed and sold homes with specific features and amenities. - Partington claimed that the home he purchased did not conform to the representations made during the sales process. - Issues cited by Partington included substandard construction, violations of local building codes, and failure to provide certain promised amenities. **Legal Issues:** The central legal issues in this case revolved around the enforceability of the contract, whether Del Webb Communities engaged in deceptive practices, and the extent of liability for any alleged breaches of agreement. **Arguments:** - **Plaintiff (Partington):** - Asserted that Del Webb Communities misled him regarding the quality and features of the home. - Claimed damages for the cost of repairs needed to meet promised standards and for the diminished value of the property. - **Defendant (Del Webb Communities, Inc.):** - Denied any wrongdoing and argued that Partington had ample opportunity to conduct his own inspections and assessments prior to closing the sale. - Contended that any issues raised were within normal expectations and did not rise to the level of breach of contract or misrepresentation. **Court's Analysis:** The court reviewed evidence, including the sales contract, promotional materials from Del Webb Communities, and expert testimony regarding building standards. The court assessed whether any discrepancies between stated features and the actual home constituted misrepresentation and whether the claims were within the scope of normal business practices in real estate development. **Conclusion:** The outcome of the case ultimately hinged on the interpretation of the contractual obligations and the standards expected in the home construction industry. The court's ruling would clarify the responsibilities of developers in representing their products and the legal recourse available to homeowners in cases of perceived misrepresentation or construction defects. **Impact:** This case could set a precedent for future litigation involving residential real estate contracts, particularly in how marketing representations are viewed in the context of consumer protection laws. It underscores the importance of clear communication and adherence to promised standards within the real estate development industry. **Note:** Specific details such as the final ruling, damages awarded, or other judgments were not included due to the absence of such information in the original request. Please verify with actual court documents for completeness.

Del Webb Communities, Inc. v. Charles Partington


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available