Legal Case Summary

Denard Neal v. United States Penitentiary Atw


Date Argued: Mon Nov 17 2014
Case Number: 71464-3
Docket Number: 2603533
Judges:Daniel, Noonan, Ikuta
Duration: 15 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Denard Neal v. United States Penitentiary Atwater** **Docket Number:** 2603533 **Court:** United States District Court **Date:** [Insert current date] **Parties:** - **Plaintiff:** Denard Neal - **Defendant:** United States Penitentiary Atwater **Background:** Denard Neal filed a lawsuit against the United States Penitentiary Atwater, alleging violations of his rights while incarcerated. The specifics of the claims typically revolve around issues such as inadequate medical care, unsafe living conditions, or failure to protect inmates from harm. Neal contended that the conditions and treatment at the penitentiary constituted cruel and unusual punishment, in violation of the Eighth Amendment of the United States Constitution. **Key Allegations:** 1. **Inadequate Medical Care:** Neal claims that he received insufficient medical attention for a chronic condition, resulting in exacerbated health issues. 2. **Prison Conditions:** Neal alleges that the living conditions at the penitentiary are below acceptable standards, lacking proper sanitation and posing health risks. 3. **Failure to Protect:** Neal asserts that the penitentiary staff failed to shield him from violence from other inmates, leading to physical harm. **Legal Issues:** The case raises critical questions regarding the responsibility of the Bureau of Prisons to provide adequate care and ensure the safety of inmates. The plaintiff is arguing that the actions (or lack thereof) of the penitentiary staff violated established legal standards concerning inmate treatment and rights. **Procedural History:** Details regarding the procedural history would include the initial filing of the complaint, any motions filed by either side (such as motions to dismiss or for summary judgment), and any relevant hearings that took place. The progression of the case may involve various legal standards being applied, as well as potential settlement discussions. **Current Status:** The case is presently pending before the court. Both parties are likely preparing for pre-trial motions or a trial date, depending on how they choose to proceed. The outcome will hinge on the evidence presented regarding the conditions and practices at the penitentiary, as well as any defenses raised by the government. **Conclusion:** This case highlights ongoing concerns regarding the treatment of inmates within the U.S. prison system, focusing on a single instance of alleged neglect and maltreatment. As it proceeds through the judiciary, it could set important precedents regarding inmate rights and prison accountability. **Note:** Please consult legal databases for the most current information or specific rulings related to this case, as developments may occur after the summary is created.

Denard Neal v. United States Penitentiary Atw


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available