Legal Case Summary

Dolores Piper v. Joshua Cabillo


Date Argued: Thu Oct 20 2016
Case Number: 14-16830
Docket Number: 4481165
Judges:Callahan, Hurwitz, Molloy
Duration: 21 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

### Case Summary: Dolores Piper v. Joshua Cabillo **Docket Number:** 4481165 **Court:** [Insert Court Name] **Date:** [Insert Date of Decision] **Parties:** - **Plaintiff:** Dolores Piper - **Defendant:** Joshua Cabillo **Background:** The case of Dolores Piper v. Joshua Cabillo centers around a dispute arising from an incident that occurred on [insert date of incident]. Dolores Piper, the plaintiff, alleges that Joshua Cabillo, the defendant, was negligent, which resulted in personal injuries sustained by her. **Facts:** 1. On [insert date], Piper was involved in an incident where she claims Cabillo failed to adhere to [specify rules, regulations, or traffic laws], leading to [description of the incident, e.g., a collision or accident]. 2. As a result of the incident, Piper experienced [list injuries or damages], which necessitated [medical treatment, lost wages, etc.]. 3. Piper filed a lawsuit seeking compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and any other associated costs. **Key Issues:** - Whether Joshua Cabillo was negligent in his actions leading up to the incident. - Whether Dolores Piper can prove that Cabillo’s negligence directly caused her injuries. **Arguments:** - **Plaintiff's Argument:** Piper contends that Cabillo acted recklessly and failed to follow [insert relevant laws/rules], which directly led to the injuries she suffered. She presents evidence including [witness testimonies, medical records, etc.] to support her claims. - **Defendant's Argument:** Cabillo denies negligence, asserting that [state his defense or counter-arguments, such as claiming the plaintiff was at fault or that circumstances beyond his control caused the incident]. He presents his own evidence, including [exhibits, witness statements] to dispute Piper’s claims. **Court's Analysis:** The court examined the evidence presented by both parties, focusing on the standards for negligence which require establishing duty, breach, causation, and damages. The analysis included [describe any key legal considerations or precedents]. **Conclusion:** After reviewing the evidence, the court [state the court's decision, e.g., ruled in favor of the plaintiff, awarded damages, or dismissed the case]. The court emphasized [any key points made in the ruling regarding negligence, liability, or damages]. **Outcome:** - The court ruled in favor of [Piper/Cabillo]. - [Detail any awarded damages or specific orders from the court, e.g., compensatory damages, future medical care, etc.]. This case highlights critical issues surrounding personal injury claims, the burden of proof in cases of alleged negligence, and the importance of presenting a robust case supported by credible evidence. **Next Steps:** - [Outline any potential appeals or further legal actions if applicable.] (Note: This summary is hypothetical and would need to be tailored to include specific details from the actual case, including dates, legal arguments, and the court's final decision.)

Dolores Piper v. Joshua Cabillo


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available