Legal Case Summary

Donald Waters v. Harold Clarke


Date Argued: Wed Jan 29 2014
Case Number: 14-20450
Docket Number: 2591304
Judges:Paul V. Niemeyer, Dennis W. Shedd, Stephanie D. Thacker
Duration: 52 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Donald Waters v. Harold Clarke** **Docket Number:** 2591304 **Court:** [Specific court name, if applicable] **Date of Decision:** [Insert date of decision if known] **Overview:** The case of Donald Waters v. Harold Clarke involves a legal dispute where the petitioner, Donald Waters, challenges the actions or decisions made by Harold Clarke, who is typically a representative of a department of corrections or similar authority. **Facts:** Donald Waters, the petitioner, claims that Harold Clarke, in his capacity as [specific role, e.g., Warden of a correctional facility], engaged in actions that violated Waters' rights during his incarceration. The details of the case may include allegations of improper treatment, violation of due process rights, or issues regarding conditions of confinement. **Issues:** The central legal issues in this case may involve: 1. Whether the actions taken by Harold Clarke were within the scope of his authority. 2. Whether Donald Waters' rights were violated under state or federal law, particularly regarding corrections and inmate rights. 3. Any potential violations of the Eighth Amendment concerning cruel and unusual punishment. **Holding:** The court's decision may hinge on the interpretation of constitutional rights as they apply to inmates, as well as the application of relevant precedents regarding the authority of prison administrators. **Outcome:** Depending on the ruling, the court may have ordered remedial measures for Donald Waters, which could include changes in prison policy, monetary damages, or other forms of relief. **Implications:** The outcome of this case could have significant implications for the treatment of inmates, the authority of correctional officials, and the enforcement of constitutional protections within the corrections system. **Conclusion:** This case exemplifies ongoing issues regarding inmate rights and the responsibilities of correctional administrators. The decision reached in this case will contribute to the broader legal landscape concerning the treatment of incarcerated individuals and the interpretation of their rights under the law. **Note:** For further details on specific legal arguments, the court's reasoning, and the implications of the decision, please refer to the full court opinion or official court records.

Donald Waters v. Harold Clarke


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available