Legal Case Summary

Eric Shine v. USA


Date Argued: Tue Jan 14 2014
Case Number: 11-72740
Docket Number: 7836788
Judges:Dearie, Graber, Nguyen
Duration: 28 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Eric Shine v. USA** **Docket Number:** 7836788 **Court:** [Specify Court, e.g., United States Court of Appeals] **Filing Date:** [Specify Date] **Parties Involved:** - **Appellant:** Eric Shine - **Appellee:** United States of America **Background:** Eric Shine appealed a decision made by the lower court regarding [briefly outline the nature of the case, e.g., federal tax issues, civil rights concerns, etc.]. The case revolves around [provide pertinent facts about the case, including the events leading to the lawsuit, any governmental actions involved, and the legal claims made by Shine]. **Legal Issues:** The primary legal issues in the case include: 1. [Issue 1: e.g., Whether the actions taken by the government were lawful.] 2. [Issue 2: e.g., Whether Shine's rights were violated under specific statutes or constitutional provisions.] 3. [Any additional issues that may be relevant.] **Arguments:** - **Appellant's Argument:** Shine contended that [summarize Shine's main arguments and legal rationale, citing specific laws or precedents that support his position]. - **Appellee's Argument:** The government argued that [summarize the government's response and the legal basis for their actions, including any defenses they raised]. **Decision:** The court ultimately ruled in favor of [either Eric Shine or the United States]. The ruling was based on [summarize the court's reasoning and the legal principles applied to reach the decision]. **Impact:** The decision has implications for [discuss any broader impacts, such as precedents it sets, effects on related cases, or implications for the legal landscape]. It serves as a significant illustration of [highlight what the case exemplifies in terms of legal principles, rights, or governmental authority]. **Conclusion:** The case of Eric Shine v. USA demonstrates the complex interplay between individual rights and government power. As part of the ongoing legal discourse, it raises important questions regarding [highlight any continuing legal issues or discussions that arise from the case]. **Notes:** - Future implications may depend on whether the case will be appealed further or if legislative changes might arise in response to the ruling. - [Any additional notes about further legal commentary, public response, or related cases.] --- **Disclaimer:** This summary is an example and may not reflect real case details. For accurate and specific information, consult official legal sources or court documents.

Eric Shine v. USA


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available