Legal Case Summary

Gail Michelman v. Lincoln National Life Insuranc


Date Argued: Mon Jun 04 2012
Case Number: 11-35393
Docket Number: 7839258
Judges:Gee, Silverman, Murguia
Duration: 39 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Gail Michelman v. Lincoln National Life Insurance** **Docket Number:** 7839258 **Court:** [Specify Court, e.g., U.S. District Court, etc.] **Filing Date:** [Insert Date] **Parties Involved:** - **Plaintiff:** Gail Michelman - **Defendant:** Lincoln National Life Insurance Company **Background:** Gail Michelman filed a lawsuit against Lincoln National Life Insurance Company alleging denial of benefits under her insurance policy. The plaintiff claimed that the insurer wrongfully denied her claims for disability benefits related to a medical condition, citing breach of contract and failure to act in good faith. **Facts of the Case:** - Gail Michelman purchased a long-term disability insurance policy from Lincoln National Life Insurance. - Following the onset of her medical condition, Michelman submitted a claim for disability benefits. - The claim was initially approved but later denied by the insurer after subsequent reviews, which led to the plaintiff filing an appeal. - Michelman contended that the denial was unjustified and that Lincoln National failed to provide adequate reasoning or evidence to support its decision. **Legal Issues:** - Whether Lincoln National Life Insurance Company acted in bad faith when denying the plaintiff's claim. - Whether the insurance company breached the terms of the insurance contract. - The appropriate standards for evaluating claims under long-term disability policies. **Court's Analysis:** The court examined the policy provisions, the medical evidence presented, and the procedures followed by Lincoln National in processing the claim. It considered the legitimacy of the insurer's reasons for denying the claim and whether the company fulfilled its obligations under the contract. **Conclusion:** The court rendered a decision based on the evidence and legal standards applicable to insurance claims and contracts. The ruling addressed both the claim of bad faith and the breach of contract allegations, determining the outcome in favor of either the plaintiff or defendant. **Outcome:** [Insert Outcome, e.g., The court ruled in favor of Gail Michelman, ordering Lincoln National to pay the denied benefits plus damages for bad faith, or conversely, the court ruled in favor of Lincoln National, upholding their decision to deny benefits.] **Comments:** This case highlights significant issues surrounding the handling of disability claims by insurance companies and the need for clear communication and adherence to the contractual obligations outlined in insurance policies. --- **Note:** This summary should be tailored further based on specific court rulings, legal interpretations, and details pertinent to the case. Additionally, adapting to correct and actual case information is crucial, as this summary is based on a hypothetical scenario.

Gail Michelman v. Lincoln National Life Insuranc


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available