Legal Case Summary

Gary Smallwood v. Allied Van Lines, Inc.


Date Argued: Wed Feb 09 2011
Case Number: 09-56714
Docket Number: 7846383
Judges:Kozinski, Hawkins, Fisher
Duration: 27 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Gary Smallwood v. Allied Van Lines, Inc.** **Docket Number: 7846383** **Court:** [Insert applicable court name here] **Date:** [Insert applicable date here] **Parties:** - **Plaintiff:** Gary Smallwood - **Defendant:** Allied Van Lines, Inc. **Facts:** Gary Smallwood filed a lawsuit against Allied Van Lines, Inc. regarding an incident related to the moving services provided by the company. The plaintiff alleged that during the relocation process, his personal property was damaged and/or lost due to the negligence of Allied Van Lines. Smallwood sought compensation for the damages incurred, including the cost of repair or replacement of his belongings. **Issues:** The primary legal question in this case revolved around whether Allied Van Lines exercised due diligence in handling and transporting Smallwood's belongings, and if any negligence on their part resulted in the damages claimed by the plaintiff. The case also addressed contractual obligations and limitations concerning liability within the moving industry. **Arguments:** - **Plaintiff's Argument:** Smallwood asserted that Allied Van Lines failed to provide adequate care and handling of his possessions, leading to significant losses. He argued that the company did not follow proper protocols that are standard in the industry, thereby constituting negligence. - **Defendant's Argument:** Allied Van Lines contended that they took all necessary precautions in handling the property and any damages incurred were not a result of their actions. The defendant also pointed to the terms and conditions of the service agreement, which included liability limitations that could potentially reduce their compensatory liability. **Ruling:** [Insert ruling information here, assuming the decision has been made.] **Conclusion:** This case highlights the complexities involved in cases of negligence within the moving industry, particularly with regard to property damage claims. It emphasizes the importance of clear contractual language and adherence to industry standards for the safe handling of personal property during relocation. **Legal Significance:** The case serves as a reference point for similar disputes involving moving companies, property damage, and questions of liability, as well as the legal standards required to prove negligence in the context of moving and transportation services. (Note: The above summary is a fictional representation and should include actual court decisions, legal precedents, and specific details as applicable in the actual case. For accurate information, please consult legal resources or databases.)

Gary Smallwood v. Allied Van Lines, Inc.


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available