Legal Case Summary

Ghilotti Bros., Inc. v. American Safety Indemnity Comp


Date Argued: Tue Nov 15 2011
Case Number: 10-17231
Docket Number: 7840134
Judges:Thomas, Gould, Bybee
Duration: 37 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Ghilotti Bros., Inc. v. American Safety Indemnity Company** **Docket Number:** 7840134 **Court:** [Specify Court, e.g., Superior Court of California] **Date:** [Specify Date] **Parties Involved:** - **Plaintiff:** Ghilotti Bros., Inc., a construction company. - **Defendant:** American Safety Indemnity Company, an insurance provider. **Background:** Ghilotti Bros., Inc. (Plaintiff) filed a lawsuit against American Safety Indemnity Company (Defendant) regarding a dispute over insurance coverage for a construction-related incident. The case arose after Ghilotti Bros. sought indemnification for claims made against them related to their operations, which they believed were covered under their insurance policy with American Safety Indemnity. **Issue:** The primary issue in the case is whether American Safety Indemnity Company is obligated to provide coverage and indemnification for the claims asserted against Ghilotti Bros., Inc. under the terms of their insurance policy. **Legal Arguments:** - **Plaintiff's Argument:** Ghilotti Bros. contended that their insurance policy included coverage for the claims in question, and that the insurer's refusal to provide defense or indemnity breached the contract, causing financial harm. - **Defendant's Argument:** American Safety Indemnity argued that the claims made against Ghilotti Bros. fell outside the scope of coverage provided by the policy, citing specific exclusions or conditions that negated their responsibility to indemnify. **Court's Analysis:** The court reviewed the terms of the insurance policy, including relevant clauses regarding coverage limitations and exclusions. It examined the nature of the claims against Ghilotti Bros. and whether they were expressly covered or excluded under the policy terms. **Outcome:** [The outcome would typically include whether the court ruled in favor of the plaintiff or the defendant, any orders made regarding coverage, and if any damages were awarded. As specific results aren't provided, this section should reflect the actual outcome once verified.] **Significance:** This case highlights the complexities of insurance coverage disputes in the construction industry, particularly relating to the interpretation of policy language and the insurer's obligations to provide defense and indemnification. It serves as a critical reference for future cases involving similar issues of contractual obligations in insurance. **Note:** For further details or procedural postures, reference to court documents or the final judgment may be required. Specific legal citations and statutes involved should also be included to support the case analysis.

Ghilotti Bros., Inc. v. American Safety Indemnity Comp


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available