Legal Case Summary

Glen Roe v. Carolyn Colvin


Date Argued: Tue Feb 10 2015
Case Number: 14-0899
Docket Number: 2633143
Judges:Paez, Berzon, Ezra
Duration: 33 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Glen Roe v. Carolyn Colvin** **Docket Number:** 2633143 **Court:** [Specify the court, e.g., United States District Court for the [District/State]] **Date:** [Include date of the judgment or filing] **Parties Involved:** - **Appellant:** Glen Roe - **Appellee:** Carolyn Colvin (Commissioner of Social Security) **Background:** Glen Roe filed an appeal challenging the decision made by Carolyn Colvin, who was the Commissioner of Social Security at the time. The case revolves around Roe's claim for Social Security disability benefits. **Facts:** - Glen Roe applied for Social Security disability benefits, asserting that he was unable to work due to certain medical conditions. - The Social Security Administration (SSA) denied his initial application, leading Roe to request a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ). - The ALJ ultimately upheld the denial of benefits, concluding that Roe did not meet the SSA’s criteria for disability as outlined in the Social Security Act. - Roe contended that the ALJ’s decision was not supported by substantial evidence and that he was indeed disabled as per the medical evaluations and personal testimonies provided during the hearing. **Legal Issues:** 1. Whether the ALJ properly evaluated Roe's medical evidence and subjective complaints regarding his disability. 2. Whether the findings of the ALJ were supported by substantial evidence in the administrative record. **Court Rulings:** - The court reviewed the evidence presented and the ALJ's findings. - It considered both medical opinions and testimony regarding Roe's ability to engage in gainful employment. - The court assessed the legal standard for disability under the Social Security Act and the process through which the SSA determines eligibility. **Conclusion:** The court ultimately ruled in favor of one party, affirming or reversing the ALJ’s decision based on the findings. [Summarize whether Roe's appeal was granted or denied, and any implications of the ruling. Include any instructions for further action, if applicable.] **Significance:** This case highlights the complexities involved in appeals concerning Social Security disability claims, particularly the threshold for demonstrating disability and the substantial evidence standard used in administrative reviews. **Note:** For complete details and specific legal reasoning, refer to the full court opinion.

Glen Roe v. Carolyn Colvin


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available