Legal Case Summary

Greer Coalition Incorporated v. United State Forest Service


Date Argued: Mon Feb 13 2012
Case Number: 11-15531
Docket Number: 7839764
Judges:Garbis, Tashima, Graber
Duration: 44 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Greer Coalition Incorporated v. United States Forest Service** **Docket Number:** 7839764 **Court:** [Specify the court, e.g., U.S. District Court] **Date:** [Specify the date if known] **Parties:** - **Plaintiff:** Greer Coalition Incorporated - **Defendant:** United States Forest Service **Background:** Greer Coalition Incorporated, an organization focused on environmental protections, filed a lawsuit against the United States Forest Service (USFS). The plaintiff alleged that the USFS failed to adequately consider the environmental impact of certain activities or projects within forested areas, potentially violating federal regulations and statutes designed to protect natural resources. **Legal Issues:** The central legal issue in this case revolves around the interpretation and application of federal environmental laws, including the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), and whether the USFS properly conducted environmental assessments or impact statements concerning the proposed projects. **Arguments:** - **Plaintiff's Argument:** Greer Coalition argued that the USFS did not comply with NEPA requirements by neglecting to prepare a thorough environmental impact statement (EIS) that assesses the potential harm to ecosystems and wildlife as a result of the proposed projects. The coalition contended that this oversight could lead to long-term detrimental effects on the environment. - **Defendant's Argument:** The United States Forest Service contended that they had followed appropriate procedures in assessing the environmental impacts and that any decisions made were within the scope of their authority. The agency argued that their assessments were sufficient and complied with all relevant laws and regulations. **Outcome:** [Please specify the outcome of the case if known, such as whether the court ruled in favor of Greer Coalition, the USFS, or if the case was settled, dismissed, etc.] **Significance:** This case highlights the ongoing tension between environmental protection efforts and federal agency operations, particularly in relation to land management and resource use. The outcome could have implications for future compliance with environmental laws and the standard practices of federal agencies in environmental assessments. **Conclusion:** Greer Coalition Incorporated v. United States Forest Service emphasizes the importance of thorough environmental review processes in federal projects and the necessity for organizations to hold agencies accountable in adhering to legal requirements, illustrating the critical balance between development and environmental stewardship. **Note:** The specifics of the case, including the outcome and detailed legal analyses, may vary based on further findings and court rulings. Please consult legal databases or court records for comprehensive details.

Greer Coalition Incorporated v. United State Forest Service


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available