Legal Case Summary

Hambleton Bros. Lumber v. Balkin Enter


Date Argued: Wed Sep 15 2004
Case Number: 03-35480
Docket Number: 7859362
Judges:Wallace, Gould, Berzon
Duration: 26 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Hambleton Bros. Lumber v. Balkin Enterprises** **Docket Number:** 7859362 **Court:** [Specify Court Name if Available] **Date:** [Specify Date if Available] **Parties Involved:** - **Plaintiff:** Hambleton Bros. Lumber - **Defendant:** Balkin Enterprises **Background:** Hambleton Bros. Lumber, a supplier of lumber and related materials, filed a lawsuit against Balkin Enterprises, a construction company. The dispute arose from an alleged breach of contract concerning the supply of materials for a construction project. The plaintiff claimed that Balkin Enterprises failed to fulfill its obligations as per the agreement, which led to financial losses and delays in the project. **Legal Issues:** 1. Breach of Contract: The central issue was whether Balkin Enterprises breached the contract by not adhering to the terms agreed upon regarding the purchase and payment for materials. 2. Damages: The plaintiff sought damages for losses incurred due to the alleged breach, including costs associated with delays and additional expenses. **Arguments:** - **Plaintiff's Argument:** Hambleton Bros. Lumber contended that they delivered the materials as per the contract terms but faced issues due to Balkin Enterprises' failure to make timely payments. They argued that this breach caused significant delays and financial harm. - **Defendant's Argument:** Balkin Enterprises claimed that there were deficiencies in the materials provided, which justified their delayed payments. They emphasized that the plaintiff failed to fulfill their contractual duties, thereby exonerating them from liability. **Court’s Findings:** [To be filled based on the court's ruling or opinion if available, including any critical legal principles or interpretations established by the court.] **Conclusion:** The outcome of the case hinged on the court's interpretation of the contract terms and the assessment of damages incurred by the plaintiff. The court's decision would clarify the responsibilities of both parties in contractual agreements related to construction and material supply. **Implications:** This case highlights important aspects of contract law, particularly in the construction industry, regarding the duties of suppliers and the ramifications of failing to meet contractual obligations. **Note:** Further details such as specific rulings, judge’s opinions, and implications of the case can be added upon reviewing court records or legal databases for comprehensive insights.

Hambleton Bros. Lumber v. Balkin Enter


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available