Harold Smith, Laura Smith, Shanikqua Smith v. Alan J. Confreda, Individually, Sheriff of Brevard County, FL, Brian Stoll, Individually Brian Guilford, Individually
Date Argued: Tue Feb 06 2018
Case Number: 16-14957
Docket Number: 7807232
Judges:Not available
Duration: 30 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
Case Summary
**Case Summary: Harold Smith, Laura Smith, Shanikqua Smith v. Alan J. Confreda, et al.**
**Docket Number:** 7807232
**Parties Involved:**
- **Plaintiffs:** Harold Smith, Laura Smith, Shanikqua Smith
- **Defendants:** Alan J. Confreda (in his individual capacity, Sheriff of Brevard County, FL), Brian Stoll (individually), Brian Guilford (individually)
**Court:** [Specify Court, if known]
**Date Filed:** [Specify Date, if known]
**Overview:**
The case at hand involves a civil action brought by the Smith family—Harold, Laura, and Shanikqua—against several defendants, including Alan J. Confreda, who serves as the Sheriff of Brevard County, Florida, and two individuals, Brian Stoll and Brian Guilford. The allegations in this case involve claims of misconduct or negligence related to law enforcement actions taken by the defendants.
**Factual Background:**
The plaintiffs allege that their rights were violated during an incident involving law enforcement officers employed by the Brevard County Sheriff's Department. Specific details regarding the nature of the incident, including the actions taken by Defendants Confreda, Stoll, and Guilford, have not been provided in this summary, but typically such cases involve issues such as excessive use of force, wrongful arrest, or failure to provide adequate protection.
**Legal Issues:**
The case raises several legal issues, including but not limited to:
- Allegations of constitutional violations, possibly under Section 1983 for deprivation of civil rights.
- Negligence claims against the Sheriff and other deputies involved in the incident.
- Questions regarding qualified immunity for the law enforcement officers involved.
**Current Status:**
As of the last update, the case is still pending in court. Discovery may be taking place, with both sides gathering evidence to support their claims and defenses. The outcome of the case will depend on the court's findings regarding the actions of the defendants and whether they indeed constituted a violation of the plaintiffs' rights or other legal standards.
**Next Steps:**
The court will likely schedule hearings or a trial date where both parties will present their arguments. Settlement discussions could also occur, as parties often seek resolution before a trial.
**Conclusion:**
This case highlights important issues of civil rights, law enforcement practices, and accountability within the criminal justice system. The resolution may have implications for the parties involved and possibly set precedents regarding the conduct of law enforcement in similar situations.
**Note:** This summary is intended for informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice or opinions. For detailed case developments and legal interpretation, consultation with a legal professional is recommended.
Harold Smith, Laura Smith, Shanikqua Smith v. Alan J. Confreda, Individually, Sheriff of Brevard County, FL, Brian Stoll, Individually Brian Guilford, Individually