Legal Case Summary

Hathaway v. Colvin


Date Argued: Mon Jan 09 2017
Case Number: 16-1500
Docket Number: 4564687
Judges:Not available
Duration: 23 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Hathaway v. Colvin** **Docket Number:** 4564687 **Court:** [Insert relevant court name, if known] **Date:** [Insert date of decision or filing] **Parties Involved:** - **Appellant:** Hathaway - **Appellee:** Colvin (likely representing the Commissioner of Social Security) **Background:** The case of Hathaway v. Colvin pertains to the appellant's challenge of a decision made by the Social Security Administration (SSA) regarding the denial of benefits. The details of the appellant's situation likely involve claims for Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) or Supplemental Security Income (SSI) due to a medical condition that the appellant argues prevents them from performing substantial gainful activity. **Legal Issues:** The primary legal issue revolves around whether the SSA correctly denied Hathaway's claim for disability benefits based on the medical evidence provided, as well as the application of Social Security regulations and precedent in making such determinations. **Arguments:** - **Appellant's Position:** Hathaway argues that the Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) failed to properly consider medical evidence documenting his disabilities and symptoms. Hathaway may assert that the ALJ did not adequately assess the impact of the disabilities on his daily functioning or employability. - **Appellee's Position:** Colvin, representing the Commissioner, likely defends the decision by contending that the ALJ's ruling was supported by substantial evidence. The appellee may argue that the decision adhered to legal standards and that the ALJ correctly applied the five-step framework to evaluate disability claims. **Court’s Findings:** [Insert findings of the court, including whether the court upheld or reversed the decision of the SSA. Include details about any specific evidence or legal principles cited by the court to support its ruling.] **Conclusion:** The outcome of Hathaway v. Colvin ultimately affects the appellant's eligibility for disability benefits and provides insight into how courts interpret SSA regulations. The ruling may establish precedents regarding the evaluation of disability claims and the importance of medical evidence in determining eligibility for benefits. **Implications:** The case serves as a reference for future claimants asserting disability under similar circumstances and demonstrates the critical nature of presenting comprehensive medical documentation to support claims for Social Security benefits. [Note: Actual details regarding the court’s findings, applicable laws, and implications would be included once specific information about the case is available, as the summary above is based on common legal practice without access to case-specific details.]

Hathaway v. Colvin


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available