Legal Case Summary

Jose Valtierra v. Medtronic Inc.


Date Argued: Fri Jun 14 2019
Case Number: 17-15282
Docket Number: 15778958
Judges:Schroeder, M. Smith, Rakoff
Duration: 32 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Jose Valtierra v. Medtronic Inc.** **Docket Number:** 15778958 **Court:** [Specify the court, e.g., United States District Court] **Date:** [Insert date of filing or relevantdate] **Parties Involved:** - **Plaintiff:** Jose Valtierra - **Defendant:** Medtronic Inc. **Background:** Jose Valtierra filed a lawsuit against Medtronic Inc., alleging damages stemming from the use of a medical device manufactured by the company. Valtierra claims that the device, which was implanted during a medical procedure, failed to perform as intended, resulting in severe injury and necessitating additional medical treatment. **Allegations:** The plaintiff contends that Medtronic was negligent in the design, manufacturing, and marketing of the device. Valtierra argues that the company did not adequately warn medical professionals and patients about potential risks associated with the device. Additionally, the lawsuit claims that Medtronic violated consumer protection laws by failing to ensure the safety and efficacy of its product. **Legal Claims:** Valtierra’s legal claims include: - Negligence - Product liability - Breach of warranty - Failure to warn **Defendant's Position:** Medtronic Inc. has denied the allegations and argues that the device was properly designed, manufactured, and marketed in accordance with industry standards and regulations. The company contends that any adverse effects experienced by Valtierra were due to other factors unrelated to the product. **Procedural History:** The case has progressed through various stages, including motions for dismissal and discovery disputes. Both parties have engaged in pre-trial negotiations in an effort to reach a settlement but have been unable to do so. As of the latest updates, the case is set to proceed to trial. **Current Status:** The case is currently scheduled for trial, with both parties preparing to present their arguments and evidence. The outcome will hinge on the determination of whether Medtronic is liable for the injuries sustained by Valtierra and, if so, the extent of damages to be awarded. **Significance:** This case is significant as it addresses issues related to medical device safety, corporate responsibility, and consumer rights. A ruling in favor of Valtierra could have implications for similar cases and influence regulatory practices within the medical device industry. **Next Steps:** As the trial date approaches, both parties will continue to prepare their cases, including gathering expert testimonies and evidence. The court will also hold pre-trial conferences to streamline the issues and discuss any remaining pre-trial motions. [Note: This is a fictional case summary generated for illustrative purposes. Please replace placeholders with actual information if necessary.]

Jose Valtierra v. Medtronic Inc.


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available