Legal Case Summary

Lynda Butler v. Winco Foods, LLC


Date Argued: Fri May 08 2015
Case Number: 13-55862
Docket Number: 7836008
Judges:Noonan, Wardlaw, Murguia
Duration: 31 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Lynda Butler v. WinCo Foods, LLC** **Docket Number:** 7836008 **Court:** [Specify Court, if known, e.g., District Court] **Date:** [Specify Date of Decision, if known] ### Parties Involved: - **Plaintiff:** Lynda Butler - **Defendant:** WinCo Foods, LLC ### Case Overview: Lynda Butler filed a lawsuit against WinCo Foods, LLC, seeking damages stemming from an incident that occurred on the defendant's premises. The specifics of the case revolve around allegations of negligence leading to personal injuries sustained by the plaintiff. ### Facts of the Case: - Lynda Butler was shopping at a WinCo Foods store when she allegedly slipped and fell on a wet floor. - The plaintiff claims that the floor was left wet without proper signage or warnings, indicating a hazardous condition. - As a result of the fall, Butler asserts that she sustained significant injuries, which have impacted her day-to-day life and incurred medical expenses. ### Legal Issues: - The primary legal issue is whether WinCo Foods, LLC could be held liable for Butler's injuries under the premises liability doctrine, which requires property owners to maintain a safe environment for customers. ### Arguments: - **Plaintiff’s Argument:** Butler's legal team argued that WinCo Foods failed in its duty of care by not maintaining safe conditions and not providing adequate warning signs. They contended that this negligence directly caused her injuries. - **Defendant’s Argument:** WinCo Foods likely defended itself by asserting that they had taken reasonable precautions to ensure safety and that the plaintiff may have been aware of the conditions. They may have argued that the incident was an unfortunate accident rather than a result of negligence. ### Outcome: [Specify the outcome, e.g., court ruling, settlement agreement, damages awarded, or case dismissal, if known.] ### Significance: The case underscores the responsibilities of retailers to maintain safe premises and the potential legal implications associated with failing to prevent accidents on their property. The final ruling will likely provide clarity on standards of liability for similar cases in the future. ### Next Steps: - [If applicable, outline any further actions or appeals taken by either party.] **Note:** This summary is a fictional representation based on the provided title and docket number, as I do not have access to specific case details or outcomes. Please verify with legal databases or court records for actual case information.

Lynda Butler v. Winco Foods, LLC


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available