Legal Case Summary

Manuel Zarco-Romero v. Eric Holder, Jr.


Date Argued: Mon Apr 16 2012
Case Number: 09-74017
Docket Number: 7839442
Judges:Ezra, Reinhardt, Murguia
Duration: 38 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Manuel Zarco-Romero v. Eric Holder, Jr.** **Docket Number:** 7839442 **Background:** Manuel Zarco-Romero, the petitioner, challenged a decision made by the Attorney General Eric Holder, Jr., regarding his immigration status. Zarco-Romero, a native of Mexico, had been living in the United States and faced deportation based on certain charges against him, as well as his immigration status. **Legal Issues:** The core legal issues involved in this case revolved around the interpretation of immigration laws, the validity of the deportation order, and whether Zarco-Romero had any qualifying claims for relief from removal, including possible asylum or withholding of removal. **Court's Findings:** The court examined the evidence presented by Zarco-Romero, including his arguments regarding the fear of persecution if returned to Mexico. The analysis focused on the established criteria for asylum eligibility, as well as the procedural aspects of his deportation proceedings. **Decision:** Ultimately, the court ruled in favor of the respondent, Eric Holder, Jr., upholding the deportation order. The court found that Zarco-Romero did not meet the necessary criteria for relief and that his claims lacked sufficient merit. **Conclusion:** The decision reinforced the standards by which asylum claims are evaluated and underscored the challenges faced by individuals seeking to contest deportation orders. Zarco-Romero's case illustrates the complexities of immigration law and the ramifications of legal interpretation by the courts. **Outcome:** Manuel Zarco-Romero's petition was denied, and the order for his deportation was upheld, resulting in his removal from the United States pursuant to the finding that he did not qualify for protection under immigration law.

Manuel Zarco-Romero v. Eric Holder, Jr.


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available