Legal Case Summary

Marei Von Saher v. Norton Simon Museum of Art at


Date Argued: Thu Aug 22 2013
Case Number: 12-55733
Docket Number: 7837398
Judges:Pregerson, Nelson, Wardlaw
Duration: 60 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Marei von Saher v. Norton Simon Museum of Art** **Docket Number:** 7837398 **Court:** [Specify the court if known] **Date:** [Specify the date if known] **Parties Involved:** - **Plaintiff:** Marei von Saher - **Defendant:** Norton Simon Museum of Art **Background:** This case revolves around the ownership of a collection of artworks, specifically focusing on a painting by the artist Lucas Cranach the Elder. The plaintiff, Marei von Saher, asserts that she is the rightful heir to the paintings, which were allegedly looted from her family during World War II by the Nazis. The Norton Simon Museum of Art, where the painting is currently housed, is the defendant in this case, claiming rightful ownership of the artwork based on its acquisition. **Legal Issues:** The main legal issues in this case include: 1. The provenance and legal title of the painting, including claims of theft, ownership, and restitution. 2. The applicability of laws regarding art restitution and property rights after WWII. 3. The determination of jurisdiction and applicable statutes concerning art recovery. **Arguments:** - **Plaintiff's Argument:** Marei von Saher claims that the painting was wrongfully taken from her family and that she has the legal right to recover it. She argues that international law and various treaties support her claim for restitution of looted art. - **Defendant's Argument:** The Norton Simon Museum contends that they acquired the painting legally, arguing that they acted in good faith when obtaining it and citing the museum's own practices and protocols regarding the acquisition of artworks. **Outcome:** [Specify the judgment, if available, or summarize the current status of the case—whether it is still ongoing, or if a verdict was reached, etc.] **Conclusion:** The Marei von Saher v. Norton Simon Museum of Art case highlights important issues related to art recovery, ownership rights, and the implications of historical injustices. It serves as a significant example in discussions about cultural property and restitution claims, particularly involving artworks displaced during times of conflict. *Note: The specifics of the case, including arguments and outcomes, should be verified with legal documentation or court filings for accuracy and completeness.*

Marei Von Saher v. Norton Simon Museum of Art at


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available