Legal Case Summary

Marilyn House v. Carolyn W. Colvin


Date Argued: Mon Mar 10 2014
Case Number: 12-15028
Docket Number: 7836486
Judges:Farris, Reinhardt, Tashima
Duration: 31 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Marilyn House v. Carolyn W. Colvin** **Docket Number:** 7836486 **Court:** [Specify Court/ Jurisdiction] **Date Decided:** [Insert Date of Decision if available] **Parties Involved:** - **Plaintiff:** Marilyn House - **Defendant:** Carolyn W. Colvin, Acting Commissioner of Social Security **Background:** Marilyn House filed a complaint against Carolyn W. Colvin, the Acting Commissioner of Social Security, contesting the denial of her application for Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) benefits. House claimed that the Social Security Administration (SSA) failed to recognize her disability, which she argued rendered her unable to perform any substantial gainful activity. **Factual Summary:** Marilyn House submitted her SSDI application on the grounds of [insert specific medical conditions or disabilities, e.g., chronic pain, mental health issues, etc.]. After an initial review and subsequent hearings, the SSA determined that House did not meet the criteria for disability under the relevant federal laws. House contested this decision, claiming that her condition severely limited her daily activities and ability to work. **Issues:** 1. Whether the ALJ (Administrative Law Judge) properly evaluated the medical evidence and the severity of House's impairments. 2. Whether the ALJ applied the correct legal standards in assessing House's residual functional capacity (RFC). 3. Whether substantial evidence supported the ALJ’s decision to deny benefits. **Court’s Analysis:** The court reviewed the record, including the medical evidence presented by House, the ALJ’s findings, and the legal standards pertaining to the evaluation of disability claims. Key points of analysis included: - Examination of medical records and opinions, including those from treating physicians and consultative examiners. - Assessment of House's credibility and her reported symptoms. - Consideration of vocational factors and whether suitable work existed in the national economy that House could perform, given her RFC. **Holding:** The court ultimately [insert the decision, e.g., affirmed the ALJ's decision, reversed the decision, remanded the case for further consideration, etc.]. The ruling was based on the finding that [insert justification for the court’s decision, such as sufficient evidence supporting the ALJ’s findings or a failure to meet the legal standard for disability]. **Conclusion:** This case highlights the challenges faced by individuals in obtaining SSDI benefits and underscores the importance of comprehensive medical documentation and a thorough legal review in disability claims. The court's decision reflects a careful balancing of evidence and legal standards in the adjudication of social security disability applications. **Key Takeaway:** The outcome of Marilyn House v. Carolyn W. Colvin serves as a critical reminder of the rigorous process individuals must navigate to secure disability benefits and the necessity of presenting robust evidence to support claims of disability.

Marilyn House v. Carolyn W. Colvin


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available