Legal Case Summary

Marilyne Hennessey v. Nancy Berryhill


Date Argued: Wed Oct 11 2017
Case Number: 16-15828
Docket Number: 6167976
Judges:O'scannlain, Bybee, Mahan
Duration: 22 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Marilyne Hennessey v. Nancy Berryhill** **Docket Number:** 6167976 **Court:** United States District Court **Date:** [Insert date of decision] **Background:** Marilyne Hennessey, the plaintiff, brought a case against Nancy Berryhill, the Acting Commissioner of Social Security. Hennessey had previously applied for Social Security disability benefits, which were denied by the Administration. Following the denial, she sought judicial review of the decision, challenging the findings and arguing that the decision was not supported by substantial evidence. **Issue:** The primary issue in the case was whether the administrative decision to deny Hennessey’s claim for Social Security disability benefits was appropriate and supported by sufficient evidence. **Arguments:** Hennessey contended that the Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) failed to properly consider the medical evidence and the impact of her impairments on her ability to work. She argued that the ALJ should have given more weight to the opinions of her treating physicians and that the findings were inconsistent with her documented symptoms and limitations. Nancy Berryhill, on behalf of the Social Security Administration, maintained that the ALJ's decision was based on a thorough review of the medical evidence and was consistent with the applicable legal standards. The defense argued that the ALJ properly assessed credibility and that the decision was supported by substantial evidence showing Hennessey’s ability to engage in alternative employment despite her impairments. **Decision:** The court reviewed the record, including the ALJ's findings and the arguments from both parties. The court upheld the administrative decision, finding that the ALJ’s determination was supported by substantial evidence. The court emphasized that the ALJ had adequately considered the medical evidence and had provided a reasonable justification for the weight given to the opinions of treating physicians. **Conclusion:** The case resulted in a ruling in favor of Nancy Berryhill, affirming the denial of Social Security disability benefits to Marilyne Hennessey. The court concluded that the ALJ acted within its discretion and that the decision was appropriately supported by the evidence presented. **Note:** [Insert any additional relevant information about appeals, subsequent actions, or implications of the decision, if applicable.]

Marilyne Hennessey v. Nancy Berryhill


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available