Legal Case Summary

Oregon Restaurant and Lodging v. Thomas Perez


Date Argued: Fri Jul 10 2015
Case Number: 14-3026
Docket Number: 2673199
Judges:Pregerson, Smith, Owens
Duration: 53 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Oregon Restaurant and Lodging Association v. Thomas Perez** **Docket Number:** 2673199 **Court:** United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit **Date Filed:** (Specific date not provided; please refer to the court documents for exact filing dates) **Parties Involved:** - **Plaintiff/Appellant:** Oregon Restaurant and Lodging Association (ORLA) - **Defendant/Appellee:** Thomas Perez, in his official capacity as Secretary of the U.S. Department of Labor **Background:** This case involves a dispute between the Oregon Restaurant and Lodging Association, representing the interests of the hospitality industry in Oregon, and Thomas Perez, the then-Secretary of the U.S. Department of Labor. The association challenged certain regulations implemented by the Department of Labor that they argued were detrimental to their industry. **Legal Issues:** The core issues in this case included: - Whether the Department of Labor’s regulations regarding wage and hour laws were legally applied to the hospitality industry. - Whether these regulations imposed undue burdens on restaurants and lodging establishments in Oregon. **Arguments:** - The plaintiff argued that the new regulations were overly restrictive and did not consider the unique operational challenges faced by the hospitality sector. They claimed that these rules would lead to increased operational costs, potentially resulting in job losses and reduced services offered to the public. - The defendant maintained that the regulations were designed to protect workers' rights and ensure fair wages across all industries, including hospitality. **Outcome:** The appellate court's ruling provided clarity on the application of federal regulations to the hospitality industry in Oregon. While specifics on the outcome are reliant on the court's judgment, the case could establish important precedents regarding the balance between regulatory compliance and the operational needs of small businesses in the restaurant and lodging sector. **Significance:** This case highlights the ongoing tension between federal regulatory authority and the economic realities faced by specific industries. The decision could affect not only the immediate parties involved but also set a precedent for similar future challenges by trade associations and businesses against federal regulations in various sectors. **Conclusion:** The Oregon Restaurant and Lodging Association v. Thomas Perez case reflects critical discussions about labor regulations, economic impacts on specific industries, and the broader implications of federal oversight in the context of local businesses. Further developments or the court's final rulings could impact policymaking and business operations within the hospitality industry significantly. (Note: For a comprehensive legal analysis, further details and specific case law references would be required, and interested parties should consult the actual court documents.)

Oregon Restaurant and Lodging v. Thomas Perez


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available