Legal Case Summary

Paul Melcher v. City of San Luis


Date Argued: Fri Oct 09 2009
Case Number: 08-15866
Docket Number: 7848915
Judges:Wallace, Thompson, Thomas
Duration: 22 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Paul Melcher v. City of San Luis** **Docket Number:** 7848915 **Court:** [Specify Court if known, e.g., United States District Court] **Filed:** [Insert Date] **Parties Involved:** - **Plaintiff:** Paul Melcher - **Defendant:** City of San Luis **Background:** Paul Melcher filed a lawsuit against the City of San Luis, asserting claims arising from [briefly outline the nature of the dispute, e.g., a personal injury, civil rights violation, employment discrimination, etc.]. The case centers on [detail the critical facts leading to the lawsuit, including any relevant incidents, actions taken by the City, and specific grievances expressed by Melcher]. **Legal Issues:** The plaintiff raised several legal issues, including: - [Issue 1: e.g., Negligence, violation of constitutional rights, etc.] - [Issue 2: e.g., Failure to adhere to city ordinances, etc.] - [Issue 3: Any additional claims raised by the plaintiff] **Arguments:** 1. **Plaintiff's Argument:** Melcher contends that [summarize the core arguments presented by the plaintiff, including any evidence or witness testimony]. He argues that the City’s actions (or inactions) had direct consequences leading to [effect on Melcher, e.g., injury, loss, discrimination]. 2. **Defendant's Argument:** The City of San Luis argues that [summarize the defense's position, including any counterarguments or legal defenses raised by the City]. The City maintains that they acted within their legal rights and responsibilities, asserting that [specific defenses or justifications]. **Procedural Posture:** The case has undergone [describe any notable pre-trial activities, motions filed (e.g., motions to dismiss, summary judgment), and where the case stands in the litigation process]. **Current Status:** As of [insert date], the court is set to [indicate upcoming proceedings, such as trial dates, hearings, or pending motions]. The outcome of the case remains undetermined as both parties await court action. **Conclusion:** This case represents a significant legal dispute between an individual and a municipal government, encapsulating issues of [summarize key themes, such as accountability, public safety, civil rights, etc.]. The final decision will likely impact not only the parties involved but also set precedents for similar cases in the future. **Note:** For further details, including court rulings and procedural decisions, please refer to the official court documents related to Docket Number 7848915.

Paul Melcher v. City of San Luis


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available