Legal Case Summary

Petro Star v. BP Oil Supply Co.


Date Argued: Tue Jun 03 2014
Case Number: 13-35007
Docket Number: 7836156
Judges:Wallace, Graber, Wardlaw
Duration: 52 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Petro Star, Inc. v. BP Oil Supply Co., Docket No. 7836156** **Court**: [Specify Jurisdiction] **Filing Date**: [Specify Date] **Background**: Petro Star, Inc. (Plaintiff) filed a lawsuit against BP Oil Supply Co. (Defendant) regarding a dispute related to a supply contract for petroleum products. The parties had entered into a contractual agreement governing the sale and purchase of various oil products, which included terms on pricing, delivery schedules, and quality standards. **Legal Issues**: The primary legal issues in this case revolve around: 1. Breach of Contract: Petro Star alleges that BP Oil Supply Co. failed to deliver the contracted quantities of oil products within the agreed timeframe, resulting in financial losses for Petro Star. 2. Quality of Goods: Petro Star claims that the products supplied by BP did not meet the quality specifications outlined in the contract, which also led to additional costs and damages. **Facts**: - Petro Star entered into a supply agreement with BP Oil Supply Co., which stipulated specific delivery times, quantities, and quality controls for the oil products. - Disputes arose when Petro Star received a shipment that was either late or did not conform to the quality standards specified in the contract. - Petro Star provided written notices to BP regarding the breaches, seeking resolution and damages for losses incurred. **Arguments**: - **Plaintiff (Petro Star)**: Asserts that BP's failure to deliver as per the contract constitutes a breach and is seeking damages for lost profits and costs associated with securing alternative supplies. - **Defendant (BP Oil Supply Co.)**: May argue that any delays were due to unforeseen circumstances beyond their control or that Petro Star failed to provide adequate notice regarding quality concerns, which would limit BP's liability. **Ruling**: The court's ruling on the case would depend on the interpretation of the contractual terms, the evidence provided regarding the breaches, and arguments from both parties regarding liability and damages. **Conclusion**: This case highlights the complexities involved in contracts within the oil supply chain, particularly issues related to performance obligations such as timely deliveries and product quality. The outcome will have significant implications for both parties regarding their contractual rights and future business dealings. **Note**: Further details regarding the court's decision, conclusions, and any awarded damages should be retrieved from the official court documents or opinions when available.

Petro Star v. BP Oil Supply Co.


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available