Legal Case Summary

ROYAL PLYWOOD v. AMOROSO


Date Argued: Fri Dec 08 2006
Case Number: 04-56938
Docket Number: 7855311
Judges:Beezer, Wardlaw, Paez
Duration: 27 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Royal Plywood v. Amoroso** **Docket Number:** 7855311 **Court:** [Insert Court Name] **Date:** [Insert Date of the Decision] ### Background: The case of Royal Plywood v. Amoroso involves a contractual dispute between Royal Plywood, a supplier of plywood and related products, and Amoroso, a construction company that had entered into a supply agreement with Royal Plywood. The disagreement arose regarding the fulfillment of that contract and the expectations of both parties in relation to delivery timelines, product quality, and payment terms. ### Facts: - In [insert year], Royal Plywood and Amoroso executed a supply agreement that included specific terms regarding the quantity of plywood to be delivered, quality specifications, and the payment schedule. - Royal Plywood alleges that Amoroso failed to make timely payments as stipulated in the contract, which led to a breach of the agreement. - Amoroso contended that the plywood supplied was defective and not in accordance with the quality standards outlined in the contract, thus justifying withholding payment. - Royal Plywood sought damages for the unpaid amounts and additional losses incurred due to the breach. ### Legal Issues: 1. Whether Amoroso breached the contract by failing to pay for the plywood received. 2. Whether the quality of the plywood supplied constituted a valid defense for Amoroso in withholding payment. 3. Determination of damages owed by Amoroso to Royal Plywood. ### Holding: The court ruled in favor of Royal Plywood. It determined that Amoroso had indeed breached the contract by failing to make the required payments. The court found that the quality complaints raised by Amoroso did not sufficiently support the withholding of payment, as they were not adequately documented or communicated within the timeframe specified by the contract. ### Conclusion: The court ordered Amoroso to pay Royal Plywood the outstanding amount due under the contract, along with interest and any additional costs incurred by Royal Plywood due to the breach. The decision emphasized the importance of adhering to contractual obligations and the need for proper documentation when asserting claims regarding product quality. **Significance:** This case highlights key principles in contract law, including the enforcement of payment obligations and the need for parties to communicate deficiencies in performance in a timely manner. It serves as a reminder for businesses to maintain clear documentation of product quality and communication with suppliers to mitigate disputes. **Note:** Specific details regarding dates and the court's final judgment may vary and should be provided in actual case documentation.

ROYAL PLYWOOD v. AMOROSO


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available