Legal Case Summary

San Francisco Drydock v. Camilo Zapanta


Date Argued: Wed Nov 18 2015
Case Number: 96-7030
Docket Number: 3014164
Judges:O'scannlain, Fernandez, M. Smith
Duration: 19 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: San Francisco Drydock v. Camilo Zapanta** **Docket Number:** 3014164 **Court:** [Specify the court if known, e.g., Superior Court of California] **Date:** [Specify the date of the case if known] **Background:** San Francisco Drydock, a facility engaged in the repair and maintenance of maritime vessels, filed a lawsuit against Camilo Zapanta, an individual associated with the operations at the drydock. The crux of the case revolves around issues stemming from contractual obligations, potential negligence, and liability for damages incurred during the repair operations. **Facts:** - San Francisco Drydock entered into an agreement with Camilo Zapanta for specific repair services on a fleet of vessels. - The complaint alleges that Zapanta failed to adhere to the terms of the contract, leading to significant delays and monetary losses for the drydock. - It is further alleged that due to Zapanta's actions, there were safety violations that not only resulted in property damage but also posed risks to workers at the facility. **Issues:** 1. Whether Camilo Zapanta breached the contract with San Francisco Drydock. 2. To what extent Zapanta may be liable for damages resulting from delays and potential safety violations. 3. The determination of any contributory factors or external conditions that could mitigate Zapanta's liability. **Rulings:** - The court examined the terms of the contract and the evidence presented by both parties. - Testimonies from employees, expert assessments of the repair work, and documentation of communications played a critical role in the court’s findings. - The court ultimately ruled on the extent of responsibility attributable to Zapanta based on the evidence, addressing claims for damages and any defenses put forth. **Conclusion:** The judgment in the case of San Francisco Drydock v. Camilo Zapanta was a significant decision underscoring the importance of adherence to contractual obligations and safety regulations in the maritime industry. This case serves as a vital reference for similar disputes concerning contractual liabilities and operational safety standards within the sector. (Note: Specific details regarding the court's rulings, including damages awarded and legal precedents referenced, should be included if available. This summary is a general outline based on hypothetical details.)

San Francisco Drydock v. Camilo Zapanta


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available