Legal Case Summary

Sandra Shockley v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue


Date Argued: Tue Jun 20 2017
Case Number: 16-13473
Docket Number: 7807579
Judges:Not available
Duration: 36 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Sandra Shockley v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue** **Docket Number:** 7807579 **Court:** United States Tax Court **Date:** [Insert relevant date, if available] **Overview:** Sandra Shockley filed a case against the Commissioner of Internal Revenue concerning tax issues that arose from her filing of tax returns. The dispute primarily involved the assessment of additional tax liabilities, potential penalties, and the determination of allowable deductions. **Facts:** - Sandra Shockley was assessed additional income taxes for specific tax years as determined by the IRS. - The IRS argued that Shockley had not reported all income and had improperly claimed deductions. - Shockley contested these findings, seeking to prove that her deductions were legitimate and arguing against the classification of certain income. **Arguments:** - **Petitioner (Sandra Shockley):** Shockley claimed that she followed all tax laws and that the deductions taken were justified based on her expenses. She also argued that the IRS provided insufficient justification for their adjustments to her reported income. - **Respondent (Commissioner of Internal Revenue):** The IRS maintained that Shockley failed to provide adequate documentation for her claimed deductions and that there were discrepancies in her reported income. They sought to uphold the additional tax assessments. **Issues:** 1. Whether Shockley accurately reported her income for the tax years in question. 2. Whether the deductions claimed by Shockley were properly substantiated and allowable under tax law. 3. The application of any penalties for underreporting income. **Court’s Decision:** The Tax Court examined the evidence presented by both parties, including documentation of income and deductions. The court typically analyzes the credibility of the taxpayer's claims and the supporting evidence. The decision may have involved affirming, modifying, or denying the IRS's assessments and penalties. **Outcome:** The final ruling of the Tax Court would clarify the treatment of the disputed income and deductions for tax purposes, impacting Shockley's tax liability as well as potential penalties assessed by the IRS. **Significance:** This case underscores the importance of accurately reporting income and keeping thorough records for deductions. It highlights the rigorous standards required by the IRS and the Tax Court when evaluating disputed tax claims. **Note:** The specifics of the decision, including the final ruling and its implications, would need to be added based on the actual contents of the court's opinion if available.

Sandra Shockley v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available