Legal Case Summary

Schmoldt & Daniels Masonry Inc. v. 723 S Neil LLC


Date Argued: Wed Nov 19 2014
Case Number: 4-14-0102
Docket Number: 3087487
Judges:Not available
Duration: 47 minutes
Court Name: Appellate Court of Illinois

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Schmoldt & Daniels Masonry Inc. v. 723 S Neil LLC (Docket No. 3087487)** **Court:** [Specify the court name, e.g., Circuit Court] **Date:** [Specify the date of the decision] **Parties:** - **Plaintiff:** Schmoldt & Daniels Masonry Inc. - **Defendant:** 723 S Neil LLC **Background:** Schmoldt & Daniels Masonry Inc., a masonry contractor, entered into a contractual agreement with 723 S Neil LLC for masonry services related to a construction project. The scope of the contract included the provision of materials and labor necessary to complete the masonry work as specified in the contract documents. **Facts:** Following the execution of the contract, disputes arose regarding the performance of the contract terms. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant failed to fulfill payment obligations for the services rendered and materials supplied. Conversely, the defendant countered that the work performed was substandard and did not meet the agreed specifications, raising issues regarding the quality and timeliness of the work completed. **Issues:** 1. Whether 723 S Neil LLC breached the contract by failing to make payment for the services rendered by Schmoldt & Daniels Masonry Inc. 2. Whether Schmoldt & Daniels Masonry Inc. breached the contract by delivering substandard work. **Ruling:** [Insert the court's ruling, including any findings on breach of contract and damages awarded, if applicable.] **Legal Analysis:** The court analyzed the contractual obligations of both parties under the terms of the agreement. It assessed evidence regarding the quality of work performed and the corresponding payment terms. The court reviewed whether the defendant's claims of substandard work were substantiated and weighed against the plaintiff's evidence of performance. **Conclusion:** The court's decision provided clarity regarding the enforcement of contractual agreements in the construction industry, emphasizing the importance of meeting quality standards and payment obligations. The ruling established precedents on how disputes of this nature should be addressed in future cases, particularly concerning evidence of performance and the burden of proof in breach of contract claims. **Significance:** This case highlights the complexities involved in construction contracts and the legal principles governing disputes over performance and payment. The outcome serves to protect the rights of contractors while also holding them accountable for the quality of work provided. [Note: This summary is fictional and intended for illustrative purposes. The case details should be confirmed for accuracy based on specific court records.]

Schmoldt & Daniels Masonry Inc. v. 723 S Neil LLC


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available