Legal Case Summary

State of Arizona v. ASARCO LLC


Date Argued: Wed Jun 12 2013
Case Number: 11-17484
Docket Number: 7837597
Judges:Singleton, O'scannlain, Hurwitz
Duration: 50 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: State of Arizona v. ASARCO LLC** **Docket Number:** 7837597 **Court:** Superior Court of Arizona **Date:** [Insert hearing date if known] **Parties Involved:** - **Plaintiff:** State of Arizona - **Defendant:** ASARCO LLC **Background:** This case involves the State of Arizona bringing a legal action against ASARCO LLC, a mining and smelting company. The case centers around environmental concerns, particularly related to the company’s past operations impacting land, water, and public health. The complaint likely alleges that ASARCO violated state environmental laws and regulations, leading to contamination and requiring remediation efforts. **Legal Issues:** The principal legal issues in this case include: 1. **Allegations of Environmental Degradation:** The State claims ASARCO is responsible for pollution resulting from its operations. 2. **Compliance with State Laws:** Determining whether ASARCO adhered to applicable state environmental regulations. 3. **Liability for Cleanup Costs:** The State may seek to hold ASARCO accountable for the financial burden of cleanup efforts required due to contamination. **Claims:** The State of Arizona might pursue several claims against ASARCO, potentially including: - Violations of the Arizona Environmental Quality Act. - Claims for damages related to environmental cleanup. - Injunctive relief to enforce compliance with environmental regulations. **Procedural Posture:** The case may involve pre-trial motions, including motions to dismiss or for summary judgment, as well as discovery disputes regarding the evidence and expert reports needed to establish the State's claims against ASARCO. **Current Status:** As of the last update, the case may be in the discovery phase, with both parties gathering evidence. Settlement negotiations might be ongoing, although no definitive resolution is indicated at this time. **Conclusion:** The outcome of State of Arizona v. ASARCO LLC will have implications not only for the parties involved but also for environmental policy enforcement within the state. Should ASARCO be found liable, the decision could set a precedent for future environmental cases in Arizona, influencing how companies operate and are held accountable for potential environmental harm. **Note:** For specific dates, legal arguments, and detailed findings, it’s advisable to review court filings and public records associated with the case.

State of Arizona v. ASARCO LLC


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available


center>© Legal Case Summary. Data from Free Law Project and Courtlister