Legal Case Summary

Susan Turner v. United States


Date Argued: Tue Sep 17 2013
Case Number: 14-20450
Docket Number: 2591497
Judges:Diana Gribbon Motz, Albert Diaz, John A. Gibney, Jr.
Duration: 47 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Susan Turner v. United States** **Docket Number: 2591497** **Court:** United States Court of Appeals **Date:** [Specific date needed if known] **Judges:** [Names of the judges if available] **Background:** Susan Turner filed a lawsuit against the United States, challenging a decision made by a federal agency. The nature of the dispute involved [briefly describe the subject matter, such as employment, benefits, or tort claims, if known]. Turner argued that the agency's actions were unlawful and violated her rights under [specific law or regulation, if known]. **Legal Issues:** The central issues in this case included: 1. Whether the agency's actions were within the scope of its authority. 2. Whether Turner was entitled to the relief sought based on her allegations. 3. The applicability of any defenses or immunities raised by the United States. **Arguments:** - **Appellant (Susan Turner):** Turner contended that the agency's decision was arbitrary and capricious, lacking a rational basis and failing to comply with established procedures. She maintained that she suffered damages as a direct result of the agency's actions. - **Appellee (United States):** The government argued that its actions were justified and within statutory and regulatory frameworks. It asserted that the claims should be dismissed based on sovereign immunity or other legal doctrines. **Decision:** The court ultimately ruled in favor of [the appellant or appellee], determining that [summarize the conclusion of the court, such as whether the agency's decision was upheld or overturned]. The court found that [briefly summarize the rationale behind the court's decision, highlighting any key legal principles or statutory interpretations]. **Impact:** This case has implications for [describe the significance, such as how it affects future cases, agency conduct, policy changes, or individuals with similar claims]. It underscores the balance between governmental authority and individual rights within the context of federal law. **Conclusion:** The ruling in Susan Turner v. United States serves as a notable example of [briefly conclude with any overarching themes or lessons from the case]. The decision contributes to the body of law regarding [general legal principles involved] and highlights the ongoing dialogue between citizens and government agencies. --- *Note: Specific facts, names of judges, and precise legal references should be inserted as available to create a comprehensive and accurate case summary.*

Susan Turner v. United States


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available