Legal Case Summary

Tommasetti v. Barnhart


Date Argued: Fri Feb 15 2008
Case Number: 06-55999
Docket Number: 7852911
Judges:Trott, Clifton, Callahan
Duration: 19 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Tommasetti v. Barnhart, Docket Number 7852911** **Court**: United States District Court **Date**: [Specific date if available] **Docket Number**: 7852911 **Parties**: - **Plaintiff**: Tommasetti - **Defendant**: Barnhart (Commissioner of Social Security) **Background**: Tommasetti filed a claim for social security benefits, alleging that he was disabled and unable to work due to various physical and mental impairments. The claim was initially denied by the Social Security Administration, leading to Tommasetti appealing the decision. **Procedural History**: After the initial denial, Tommasetti sought a hearing before an administrative law judge (ALJ). Following the hearing, the ALJ upheld the denial of benefits. Tommasetti then appealed to the United States District Court, seeking judicial review of the decision made by the Commissioner of Social Security. **Issue**: The central issue in the case was whether the ALJ's decision to deny benefits was supported by substantial evidence and whether the proper legal standards were applied in evaluating Tommasetti's claims of disability. **Holding**: The District Court reviewed the record and the ALJ's findings. The court determined whether the ALJ had adequately evaluated Tommasetti's medical evidence, his allegations of disability, and whether the conclusions were consistent with the legal definitions of disability under the Social Security Act. **Conclusion**: The District Court's ruling (specific outcome needs to be added based on actual case outcome) either affirmed the decision of the ALJ, requiring Tommasetti to continue seeking benefits through further administrative processes, or reversed the decision, potentially awarding him the benefits he claimed. **Significance**: This case illustrates the complexities involved in the social security disability claims process, highlighting the standards of evidence required for denial and judicial review of such decisions. It serves as a critical reference for similar cases regarding the evaluation of disability claims by the Social Security Administration. (Note: This summary is a fictional construct as specific details on the actual case outcome, facts, and ruling are not present. For accurate information, the actual case documents should be referenced.)

Tommasetti v. Barnhart


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available