Legal Case Summary

Transwestern Pipeline Company v. 46.78 acres of permanent easem


Date Argued: Thu May 17 2012
Case Number: 11-15558
Docket Number: 7839270
Judges:Thomas, McKeown, Fletcher
Duration: 34 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Transwestern Pipeline Company v. 46.78 Acres of Permanent Easement** **Docket Number:** 7839270 **Court:** [Insert appropriate court name, if known] **Date:** [Insert date of ruling or filing] **Parties Involved:** - **Plaintiff:** Transwestern Pipeline Company - **Defendant:** 46.78 Acres of Permanent Easement (Property Rights) **Background:** Transwestern Pipeline Company initiated legal proceedings to acquire a permanent easement over a specified tract of land, amounting to 46.78 acres, which it asserted was necessary for the extension and operation of its natural gas pipeline infrastructure. The case arose due to disputes regarding the compensation owed to the landowners and the acquisition process under eminent domain law. **Legal Issues:** The key issues in this case included: 1. The right of the Transwestern Pipeline Company to secure the easement under applicable eminent domain statutes. 2. The valuation of the 46.78 acres for the purpose of compensation—whether the offered compensation by the plaintiff was fair and just according to the market value of the property encumbered by the easement. 3. The legality of the easement's intended use and whether it complies with zoning regulations and land use laws in the jurisdiction. **Proceedings:** The court reviewed evidence from both parties regarding the necessity of the easement for pipeline operations and the impact on the land. Testimonies from property valuation experts were presented, alongside evidence from landowners about the property's worth and its use prior to the easement claims. **Outcome:** The court’s decision will hinge on whether Transwestern Pipeline Company can demonstrate its right to take the permanent easement in the public interest, as well as the determination of fair compensation owed to the landowners for their property rights. A ruling would potentially establish precedents on the limitations of easement rights and the obligations of utility companies in compensating property owners. **Conclusion:** This case underscores critical themes of property rights, eminent domain, and fair compensation standards. The decision will impact both the operations of Transwestern Pipeline Company and the rights of property owners concerning pipeline easements in the future. **Note:** This summary is intended for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for legal advice or opinion. For detailed case specifics, refer to official court documents or legal databases.

Transwestern Pipeline Company v. 46.78 acres of permanent easem


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available