Legal Case Summary

TURNER CONSTRUCTION v. United States


Date Argued: Tue Apr 05 2011
Case Number: 146440
Docket Number: 2601667
Judges:Not available
Duration: 46 minutes
Court Name: Federal Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Turner Construction v. United States, Docket Number 2601667** **Court**: [Specify the court if known, e.g., United States Court of Federal Claims] **Date**: [Specify the date of decision if known] **Parties**: - **Plaintiff**: Turner Construction Company - **Defendant**: United States of America **Background**: Turner Construction, a prominent construction firm, filed a claim against the United States government, contesting a decision related to a federal construction contract. The dispute arose from issues surrounding unforeseen conditions encountered during the construction project, which Turner argued warranted additional compensation based on the contract's stipulations. **Legal Issues**: The core issues in this case involved: 1. Whether the conditions encountered by Turner were truly unforeseen and met the criteria for additional claims under the contract. 2. The appropriate interpretation of the contract’s provisions regarding risk allocation, change orders, and compensation adjustments. **Arguments**: - **Plaintiff's Argument**: Turner Construction contended that the unexpected conditions significantly impacted the project timeline and costs. The company argued that it had exercised due diligence in its preparations but still faced unforeseeable challenges that warranted a change order. - **Defendant's Argument**: The United States government opposed the claim, arguing that Turner had not adequately demonstrated that the conditions were unforeseen, nor had it followed the requisite procedures to formally request a change order or additional compensation. **Decision**: [Summarize the court's ruling here, including whether the claim was upheld or rejected and the reasoning behind the decision. Include details regarding any compensatory awards, if applicable.] **Impact**: This case is significant within the realm of federal contracting as it highlights the complexities surrounding unexpected conditions in construction projects. The decision serves as a precedent for future cases regarding contract interpretation, risk management, and the obligations of contractors when faced with unforeseen circumstances. **Conclusion**: Turner Construction v. United States raised critical discussions about contractual obligations and change order processes in federal construction projects. This case emphasizes the need for contractors to maintain thorough documentation and adherence to procedural requirements when addressing unforeseen conditions to protect their rights to compensation. (Note: The specifics regarding the court’s decision date, court name, the outcome, and its implications should be filled out with accurate details if they are known. The summary presented is a general framework based on common aspects of similar legal cases.)

TURNER CONSTRUCTION v. United States


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available