Legal Case Summary

United States v. ORR Water Ditch Co.


Date Argued: Wed Jul 15 2009
Case Number: 07-17001
Docket Number: 7849766
Judges:Hall, Fletcher W. , Paez
Duration: 55 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: United States v. Orr Water Ditch Co.** **Docket Number:** 7849766 **Court:** United States District Court **Location:** [Insert Location] **Filing Date:** [Insert Filing Date] **Parties Involved:** - **Plaintiff:** United States of America - **Defendant:** Orr Water Ditch Company **Background:** The case revolves around the Orr Water Ditch Company, which is involved in water diversion and irrigation operations. The United States government, as the plaintiff, brought a legal action against the company regarding issues related to the usage and management of water rights. **Legal Issues:** The primary legal questions at stake involve: 1. Allegations of unlawful water diversion or mismanagement that may violate federal regulations. 2. The rights of the Orr Water Ditch Company under various federal and state water laws. 3. The potential impact on local ecosystems and downstream water users. **Arguments:** - The **United States**, in its complaint, argues that the Orr Water Ditch Company has engaged in practices that infringe upon federally protected water rights, potentially harming the environment and disrupting the balance of water distribution in the region. The government may seek enforcement of regulations, restoration of water flow, or penalties for non-compliance. - The **Orr Water Ditch Company** defends itself by asserting its rights to operate under existing water permits and claims that its practices are compliant with applicable laws. The company may also argue that its operations do not cause significant adverse effects on the environment or other water users. **Court’s Decision:** [Insert court’s findings or rulings if available, including any injunctions, penalties, or modifications to operations mandated by the court. If the case is ongoing or settled, mention that as well.] **Significance:** This case highlights the complexities of water rights and the regulatory framework surrounding water resources in the United States. It underscores the ongoing tensions between federal oversight and local water management practices, especially in regions where water scarcity is a concern. **Conclusion:** The outcome of this case could set a precedent for how water rights are interpreted and enforced in future disputes involving federal and state jurisdiction, as well as the responsibilities of water management companies. Further developments in the case will be closely monitored by stakeholders in water resource management and environmental advocacy. **Note:** This is a hypothetical summary; please refer to actual case documents for accurate and specific details regarding the case.

United States v. ORR Water Ditch Co.


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available