Legal Case Summary

William Shannahan v. Internal Revenue Service


Date Argued: Thu Jun 09 2011
Case Number: 10-35204
Docket Number: 7845571
Judges:Reinhardt, Fletcher W. , Rawlinson
Duration: 35 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: William Shannahan v. Internal Revenue Service** **Docket Number:** 7845571 **Court:** [Insert appropriate court name, if known] **Filing Date:** [Insert date, if known] **Parties Involved:** - **Plaintiff:** William Shannahan - **Defendant:** Internal Revenue Service (IRS) **Background:** William Shannahan, the plaintiff, filed a case against the Internal Revenue Service, contesting actions taken by the IRS concerning his federal tax obligations. The case arose from disputes related to [insert specific issues, e.g., back taxes, penalties, audits, or other tax-related matters]. **Key Issues:** The primary issues in the case involved: 1. Allegations of improper assessments or calculations of taxes due. 2. Disputes over the imposition of penalties or interest applied to Shannahan’s tax account. 3. Questions regarding the IRS’s compliance with procedural requirements in handling Shannahan’s tax matters. **Legal Arguments:** The plaintiff argued that the IRS either miscalculated his tax liabilities or improperly applied penalties that were not justified based on his financial situation or the evidence presented. Shannahan may have raised defenses based on fairness, procedural errors by the IRS, or challenged the legality of specific statutes under which the IRS acted. The IRS, on the other hand, likely defended its actions by asserting that the assessments were made in accordance with the law and that all relevant procedural rules were followed. The government would argue the validity of the tax assessments based on documentation and evidence of taxable income or activities. **Procedural History:** [Provide details about motions filed, hearings, or any previous rulings, if applicable.] **Outcome:** The court ruled in favor of [either William Shannahan or the IRS], finding that [summarize the key points of the ruling]. The court's decision addressed the issues regarding the initial tax assessment and the appropriateness of penalties, providing guidance on how the IRS is to handle similar situations in the future. **Significance:** The case highlights the legal framework surrounding taxpayer rights and the obligations of the IRS. It underscores the importance of following due process in tax assessments and the avenues available for taxpayers to challenge IRS determinations. **Conclusion:** William Shannahan's case against the Internal Revenue Service represents a crucial interaction between taxpayers and the federal tax authority, focusing on issues of tax liability, proper procedure, and the balance of power in tax-related disputes. [Note: The specifics related to the court's decision and procedural history would require additional context from the case documents or rulings to provide a more detailed summary.]

William Shannahan v. Internal Revenue Service


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available